Published ahead of print on March 27, 2003, doi:10.1165/rcmb.2003-0015OC
© 2003 American Thoracic Society DOI: 10.1165/rcmb.2003-0015OC Acute Allergic Responses Induce a Prompt Luminal Entry of Airway Tissue EosinophilsDepartments of Physiological Sciences and of Clinical Pharmacology, Lund University Hospital, Lund, Sweden; and Department of Leukocyte Biology, Imperial College, London, United Kingdom Address correspondence to: Jonas S. Erjefält, Assoc. Prof. Department of Physiological Sciences, BMC F10, Lund University Hospital, 221 84, Lund, Sweden. E-mail: jonas.erjefalt{at}mphy.lu.se
Traditionally, traffic and activation of eosinophils in asthmatic airways are thought to take place during the late-phase allergic reaction. The present study tests the hypothesis that when eosinophils are present in the tissue before allergen exposure, as in chronically inflamed asthmatic airways, acute anaphylactic reactions initiate an eosinophil response. Using a guinea-pig allergic model, where eosinophilia is present at baseline conditions, the traffic of resident eosinophils was examined in vivo immediately after allergen challenge. By 2 min after challenge, eosinophils had moved up to apical epithelial positions. Within 10 min, a marked migration of eosinophils into the airway lumen was demonstrated. Along with the allergen-induced egression of eosinophils, acute luminal entry of plasma proteins and eotaxin occurred. Eosinophil egression was effectively inhibited by the antiexudative drug formoterol, whereas the proexudative drug bradykinin could in naive animals evoke a prompt luminal entry of eosinophils. In conclusion, the present study demonstrates that acute allergic reactions initiate a prompt transepithelial migration of resident eosinophils. Our data further suggest that this response in part is initiated by the plasma exudation response, which may alter the transepithelial gradient of eosinophil chemoattractants including eotaxin. We propose that prompt eosinophil response is a significant component of the acute phase of allergic reactions when occurring in airways where these cells are already present in the mucosa.
Abbreviations: bronchoalveolar lavage, BAL eosinophil peroxidase, EPO ovalbumin, OVA phosphate-buffered saline, PBS saline sodium citrate, SSC tissue nonspecific alkaline phosphatase, TNAP
Traditionally, the immediate anaphylactic airway response has been viewed as a mast cellmediated event involving bronchoconstriction and edema formation (1). By contrast, the local recruitment and activation of leukocytes and subsequent development of an eosinophil-rich "cellular inflammation" has been considered as the main feature of the late phase allergic reaction (2, 3). However, although little studied, the acute allergic reaction may potentially also trigger significant leukocyte events, especially when it overlies chronic allergic conditions, where the airway mucosa constitutively harbors elevated numbers of leukocytes (46). For example, it has been little appreciated that the plasma extravasation, which occurs immediately after an allergen provocation (7, 8), may have an effect on those leukocytes residing in the tissue at the time of challenge. After leaving the circulation from high permeability venules, extravasated plasma, with its content of leukocyte-active molecules, is distributed throughout the mucosal tissue as well as into the airway lumen (7, 9). On its passage through the lamina propria tissue, across the epithelial basement membrane, and up between the airway epithelial cells, the bulk plasma exudate, through its rich content of cytokine-binding proteins (10), apparently picks up local tissue mediators and brings them to the mucosal surface (7). We hypothesized that such a change of the mucosal biomilieu would influence those inflammatory cells that are already present in the mucosal tissues at the time of challenge. In agreement, preliminary studies examining guinea-pig large airways (which, independent of sensitization, are constitutively rich in eosinophils [11, 12]) suggest that eosinophils residing at the level of the epithelial basement membrane move to an apical epithelial position shortly after allergen challenge (13). As suggested by measurements already at 1 h after allergen exposure many of these granulocytes may actually move into the airway lumen (13). This study uses an in vivo model of acute allergic responses that specifically involves the tracheobronchial airways of guinea pigs, which are constitutionally characterized by mucosal eosinophilia as well as by a profuse superficial microcirculation (7). The focus of this study is on eosinophil trafficking induced by allergen challengeinduced immediate responses. In an attempt to explain luminal entry of eosinophils, we have further focused on acute plasma exudation responses, including the possibility that mucosal chemoattractant molecules will promptly appear on the mucosal surface along with a plasma exudate. Analysis of eotaxin was thought to be of interest because this chemokine has been shown to appear in airway lavage fluids after allergen challenge in humans (14, 15). Eotaxin has also been suggested to be responsible for the homing of eosinophils to the guinea-pig tracheal mucosa (16, 17).
Sensitization and Selective Allergen Challenge of the Tracheobronchial Airways Male guinea pigs (Dunkin-Hartley, 200 g; Möllegaard, Ejby, Denmark) were sensitized to ovalbumin by one intraperitoneal injection of 0.5 ml saline containing 100 mg Al (OH)3 (F2200; Anachemia, Montreal, Canada) and 2 µg ovalbumin (OVA) (grade III; Sigma, St. Louis, MO) (18). Three weeks after sensitization, animals were challenged by local allergen exposure of the tracheobronchial airways as previously described (13). Briefly, animals were anaesthetized by intramuscular administration (1 ml/kg) of a 2:3 ratio of Xylazine (Rompun, 20 mg/kg; Bayer, Leverkusen, Germany) and Ketamine (Ketalar, 50 mg/kg; Park Davies, Detroit, MI) and placed in an upright supine position. A thin plastic catheter was gently inserted via the mouth into the tracheal lumen 5 mm below the larynx. Next, using a microinjector (Carnegie Medical, Stockholm, Sweden) and a pump rate of 20 µl/min, the allergen (10 pmol OVA in saline) was administered to the upper airways during 2 min (control animals received saline only). Importantly, this technique evenly and selectively distributes the allergen to the mucosal surface of the large airways only (i.e., the trachea and main bronchi) (19). The experiment was terminated at 2, 10, 30, and 60 min after initiation of the allergen challenge, when lavage and tissue samples were collected for further analysis. In separate experiments the antiexudative capacity of ß2-agonists (20, 21) was used to explore the correlation between plasma extravasation and eosinophil migration. At 5 min before allergen challenge, 100 µg/kg of the ß2-agonist formoterol (AstraZeneca, R&D, Lund, Sweden) was administered by intravenous administration. After the allergen provocation the animals were kept for 30 min before the experiment was terminated.
Airway Challenge with Bradykinin
Readminstration of Tracheal Superfusates into the Upper Airways of Naive Animals
Tracheobronchial Lavage
Assessment of Plasma Extravasation and Exudation
Quantification of Luminal Eosinophils
Assessment of Tissue Expression of Eotaxin mRNA by In Situ Hybridization
Frozen sections (10 µm) were thaw-mounted onto chrome alum-coated slides and stored overnight at -20°C. They were then rapidly warmed to room temperature and immediately fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde in 0.1 M phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) (pH 7.2) for 30 min. The sections were rinsed (5 min x 2) in PBS and then acetylated by 0.25% acetic anhydride in 0.1 M triethanolamine for 10 min. Before hybridization; the sections were dehydrated through graded concentrations of ethanol, cleared in chloroform, and finally rinsed in 100% ethanol. The hybridization buffer contained 50% formamide, 4x saline sodium citrate (SSC; 1x SSC = 0.15 M NaCl, 0.015 M sodium citrate), 1x Denhardt's solution (0.02% polyvinylpyrrolidone, 0.02% Ficoll, 0.02% bovine serum albumin), 10% dextran sulfate, 0.24 mg/ml yeast tRNA, 0.5 mg/ml salmon sperm DNA, 1% sarcosyl, and 17 mM Na2HPO4. The concentration of the probes was Additional cryosections were subjected both to histochemical visualization of cyanide-resistant eosinophil peroxidase activity (13), detecting eosinophils, and in situ hybridization. Briefly, before the in situ hybridization protocol, cryosections were stained for eosinophil peroxidase (EPO; see below), rinsed, and then further processed according to the in situ hybridization protocol. In preliminary tests, it was established that neither the visualization of cyanide-resistant eosinophil peroxidase activity nor the probe labeling were altered due to the simultaneous labeling.
Luminal Content of Eotaxin
Assessment of Eosinophil Distribution in Tracheal Sections
Assessment of Eosinophil Distribution in Tracheal Whole-Mount Preparation
In Vivo Administration of Anti-Eotaxin Antibodies
Statistics
Baseline Distribution of Eotaxin mRNA and Eosinophils in Guinea Pig Upper Airways In the trachea of naive control animals, an intense expression of eotaxin mRNA was observed in the basal and mid-portion of the airway epithelium (Figures 1A and 1C) . A similar epithelial expression was observed also in the large bronchi, but was absent in more peripheral airways. In separate experiments it was demonstrated that the expression of eotaxin mRNA was significantly increased at 4 h after allergen challenge (data not shown).
EPO staining of cryosections revealed a marked tissue eosinophilia in naive animals (1,013 ± 190 eosinophils/tracheal sections). The eosinophils displayed a distribution pattern similar to that of the expression of eotaxin, i.e., an extensive occurrence that was restricted to the large airways (trachea and the large bronchi). The majority of the eosinophils were distributed within the basal portion of the airway epithelium or in the subepithelial tissue just under the basement membrane (Figures 1B and 1C). Exceedingly few eosinophils were present in the apical aspect of the airway epithelium, where expression of eotaxin mRNA was weak or absent. Combined EPO staining and in situ hybridization demonstrated a close association between eotaxin mRNA expression and eosinophils. In some short stretches of the airway epithelial lining where eosinophils were absent, the eotaxin mRNA expression was low. Where epithelial eosinophils abounded, particularly high eotaxin mRNA expression occurred. Sensitized but not allergen-challenged control animals did not differ from naive animals in their displayed eotaxin expression or eosinophil distribution.
Allergen-Induced Acute Luminal Entry of Extravasated Plasma and Eotaxin
The levels of luminal eotaxin were significantly increased acutely after allergen challenge (Figure 2B), and remained elevated throughout the experiment. A significant correlation was observed between the emergence of plasma into the airway lumen and the luminal content of eotaxin (P < 0.0001, r = 0.81).
Allergen-Induced Transepithelial Passage of Eosinophils
The transepithelial passage of eosinophils was confirmed by analysis of EPO-stained tracheal whole-mount preparations. In naive animals or the PBS-treated controls no, or exceedingly few, eosinophils were present on the mucosal surface (Figure 5A) . At 2 min after OVA challenge, scattered eosinophils were observed in the region of the epithelial apical surface (Figure 5B). At the later time points after OVA challenge, abundant eosinophils had accumulated in the epithelial surface region (Figure 5C).
Both Allergen-Induced Acute Plasma Extravasation and Luminal Entry of Eosinophils Is Effectively Inhibited by the ß2-Agonist Formoterol Formoterol, given intravenously before challenge, effectively inhibited the allergen-induced flow of extravasated plasma into the airway lumen (Figure 6A) . As examined 30 min after challenge, the formoterol-treated animals had significantly attenuated numbers of eosinophils in the airway lumen as compared with allergen-exposed nontreated animals (Figure 6B).
Local Administration of Tracheal Superfusates from Allergen-Exposed Animals Induces Luminal Entry of Eosinophils in the Absence of any Prior Plasma Extravasation Our observation of increased levels of luminal eotaxin stimulated us to test the chemoattractant and pro-extravasation properties of superfusate alone, recovered from sensitized animals 10 min after allergen exposure. Topical administration of such superfusates to naive animals resulted in a marked transepithelial migration of eosinophils without inducing any plasma extravasation response (Figure 7) . In separate control experiments, it was demonstrated that administration of superfusates from naive animals did not affect the luminal levels of eosinophils, nor were any effects on plasma extravasation observed (data not shown).
Bradykinin Induces a Prompt Luminal Influx of Eosinophils Bradykinin, a well-known inducer of plasma extravasation, was given topically to the airways. Bradykinin administration induced a plasma extravasation response within 10 min (Figure 8A) . Furthermore, bradykinin administration also resulted in increased luminal influx of eosinophils (Figure 8B).
Effect of Anti-Eotaxin Antibodies OVA-challenged animals that received control rabbit IgG serum had significantly increased levels of apical intraepithelial eosinophils (117 ± 14 apical eosinophils per cm epithelial lining) compared with saline-challenged controls (12 ± 4 apical eosinophils per cm epithelium, P = 0.002). The numbers of apical transepithelial eosinophils in OVA-challenged animals that received neutralizing anti-eotaxin antibodies at the time of challenge displayed a clear trend toward a reduction (62 ± 18 apical eosinophils per cm epithelium, P = 0.07 compared with OVA-exposed control animals).
By use of the well-controlled baseline situation provided by guinea pig large airways and a methodology that specifically assesses the airway region of interest, the present study demonstrates, for the first time, that an acute anaphylactic response evokes an immediate migration of resident mucosal eosinophils into the airway lumen. Thus, within 2 min after topical allergen challenge, eosinophils migrate to apical epithelial positions. Then, within 10 min after challenge, there is a marked migration of eosinophils into the airway lumen. Our data further suggest that acute-phase plasma extravasation, through its capacity to alter the local biomilieu and the transepithelial gradients of eosinophil chemoattractants including eotaxin, is likely to play a role in the present acute luminal entry of eosinophils. The speediness of the present eosinophil response suggests that luminal entry is a highly efficient airway mucosal response mechanism by which large numbers of tissue granulocytes can be acutely recruited to the mucosal surface. The occurrence of acute transepithelial traffic of mucosal inflammatory cells thus emerges as a first-line defense mechanism that also can be initiated during an acute anaphylactic response. The traditional view of an allergic reaction implies that it is only during the late-phase allergic response that mucosal traffic of eosinophils occurs (1, 2).This assumption is largely based on studies in animal models where, in most cases, eosinophils are absent in the tissue until several hours after challenge (23, 24). However, in common clinical situations, allergen exposure and associated acute phase responses occur in airways that already at the time of exposure have elevated numbers of eosinophils in the airway tissue (46). The constitutive and stable tracheobronchial eosinophilia that is present in guinea pig large airway tissues was, therefore, considered relevant as well as advantageous for our experimental purposes, and so were the minimal baseline numbers of eosinophils in the lumen. Thus, this species offers a rare situation in which any immediate traffic of those eosinophils present in the tissue at the time of challenge can be examined in detail in vivo. Importantly, the present assessment of eosinophil movements was performed in a model that lacks the disturbance of surgical intervention and uses low traumatic techniques for mucosal exposure specifically of the area of interest (18, 19). The present lavage method is also selective to the large airways, thus differing from the common bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) techniques that largely reflect the contribution of small intrapulmonary airways where, at least in guinea-pigs, the mucosal eosinophilia may not be pronounced until the late-phase eosinophilia develops. Indeed, studies involving the common BAL techniques in allergic guinea pigs may not detect any significant increase in luminal eosinophilia during the first hours after allergen challenge, whereas studies involving specific large airway lavage methodology do so (13). As demonstrated in the many animal models that lack airway tissue eosinophils at the time of allergen exposure, it takes 510 h after allergen exposure until eosinophils enter the airway lumen (23, 25). The present data on transepithelial migration show that in a mucosa that harbors eosinophils close to the epithelial surface, the speed by which eosinophils can be mobilized onto the airway surface increases greatly. Such immediate luminal entry of granulocytes would represent a paramount mechanism in the mucosal defense system. In accord, in the urinary and gastrointestinal tract an efficient luminal entry of granulocytes seems essential for successful neutralization of infectious organisms (2628). An exceedingly prompt luminal entry, as clearly demonstrated in this study, further supports the possibility that a major anti-infectious feature of mucosally lined organs is to let granulocytes neutralize and destroy invading organisms before their entry into the tissue, i.e., already on the mucosal surface. This mechanism would significantly reduce the risk of inflammation and damage to the host tissue. Hence, the prolonged mucosal eosinophilia occurring in chronic allergic conditions, or in healthy guinea pig airways as well as in the human gastrointestinal tract (29, 30), may represent a defense strategy providing the mucosa with the capacity to immediately mobilize leukocytes onto the mucosal surface. An acute activation of resident eosinophils may, apart from direct defense mechanisms against invading organisms, also serve immunomodulatory roles. For example, eosinophils have the capacity to release a variety of growth factors and cytokines, as well as function as antigen-presenting cells (31, 32). Further studies are warranted to investigate the effect of acute allergen-induced activation of eosinophils on the subsequent development of late phase or chronic inflammatory conditions. As indicated from the numbers of apical intraepithelial eosinophils, the transepithelial flow of cells peaks already around 10 min. Yet the lumenal content of eosinophils continues to increase at the later time points. This finding may be explained by a relatively slow clearance of lumenal eosinophils by the mucociliary transport system, leading to a gradual accumulation of eosinophils on the mucosal surface during the first hour after the initial massive transepithelial migration. As indicated by the present kinetic data, any mechanisms involved in the present luminal influx of leukocytes would be operating within one or two minutes after challenge. We hypothesized that plasma extravasation, a major acute allergic response in the airways, could be involved. Supporting this hypothesis, the allergen-induced vascular permeability response in the present model starts within 30 s after challenge by formation of endothelial gaps at postcapillary venules in the mucosal microcirculation (13, 18). Initially, bulk extravasated plasma is distributed in the lamina propria tissue. Then it moves through the epithelial basement membrane and swiftly exudes into the airway lumen through ubiquitous paracellular epithelial pathways (7, 33). Experimental data indicate that the size-independent mechanisms of luminal entry of a bulk plasma exudate reflects a hydrostatic pressure operated valve-like feature of the junctions between airway epithelial cells that unidirectionally will let through plasma macromolecules without disturbing the integrity of the epithelial lining as an absorption barrier (7). Hence, just before the initiation of the eosinophil migration, important routes into the airway lumen have been exposed to an exudate containing plasma proteins capable of acting as leukocyte activators or carriers for chemoattractants (7). Thus, through plasma exudation chemoattractant proteins may accumulate on the mucosal surface to alter the transepithelial gradients of leukocyte-active molecules. This latter aspect is supported by the present strong correlation between the appearance of exuded plasma and eotaxin in the mucosal surface fluid. Furthermore, the present application of a tracheal superfusate was sufficient to bring about luminal entry of eosinophils (in the absence of any prior plasma extravasation), suggesting that the acute allergic response did result in a biologically significant increase in surface fluid chemoattractants. Collectively, these observations suggest that chemoattractants including eotaxin, moved into the lumen by extravasated plasma, contributed to the present migration of eosinophils to the mucosal surface. In other words, luminal chemoattraction is increased, whereas there is less chemoattraction holding back the eosinophils within the mucosa. Interestingly, the plasma exudationassociated luminal entry of eosinophils was not dependent on allergen being the exudative stimulus. Thus we demonstrate here that a single pro-inflammatory mediator such as bradykinin produced prompt luminal entry of both plasma and eosinophils. Also, confirming our original demonstration of formoterol-induced inhibition of allergen-induced plasma exudation (20) we could now, in addition, demonstrate that this vascular antipermeability drug action was associated with abolition of the acute allergen-evoked luminal entry of eosinophils. A possibility of such an effect on cell traffic may need consideration also in human clinical studies, because formoterol has been shown to attenuate plasma exudation also in human bronchi (34). Interestingly, in agreement with the present increase in luminal eotaxin recent studied in humans suggests that experimental induction of a plasma extravasation can be used to transport tissue mediators into the lumen (35). This finding and the present results suggest the possibility that similar extravasation-induced luminal entry of mediators operates in humans and guinea pigs. Further work is now needed to explore potential species differences in relation to, e.g., eosinophil homing and transepithelial migration mechanisms. The traffic of eosinophils during the late phase of allergic inflammation has been extensively studied in guinea pig airways (13, 25). In this context, a role of the CC-chemokine eotaxin has been established, and the kinetics of eotaxin production and its strong relationship to the allergen-induced late phase eosinophila has been examined (17, 36). In contrast to the earlier studies in this field, the present study examines the distribution of eotaxin and its correlation with eosinophil traffic during the early stages of the acute allergic reaction. Eotaxin is constitutively expressed in guinea pig airways, and the airway epithelium has been suggested as the major site of its production (16, 37). In support of a role of eotaxin in the tissue homing of eosinophils, the present demonstration of eotaxin mRNA expression in the basal and mid-portion of the epithelium correlated well with the actual distribution of eosinophils. Our data showing that even within local tissue regions there is a spatial correlation between the expression of eotaxin and local distribution of eosinophils further underscores the view that eotaxin may regulate the homing of tracheobronchial eosinophils in naive animals (17). This notion is in line with the emerging concept that in addition to tissue recruitment, chemokines also have important roles in relocation of leukocytes within the local tissue compartments (38). It is of note that when applied topically onto human or guinea pig airways, recombinant eotaxin can, by itself, evoke an increase in BALF numbers of eosinophils (39, 40). The suggested role of eotaxin in both tissue homing and migration upon challenge complicate the use of neutralizing agents to dissect the role of eotaxin in the present model. For example, neutralization of eotaxin may disturb the normal baseline distribution of eosinophils but also attenuate a challenge-induced transepithelial migration. Nevertheless, in the present study we observed that administration of anti-eotaxin antibodies produced a trend toward a reduction of apical intraepithelial eosinophils after allergen challenge. This finding, together with the present rapid alteration of the transepithelial gradient of eotaxin, suggests a contributory role of eotaxin in the acute luminal entry of eosinophils. Considering the complexity of the mucosal molecular milieu in vivo immediately after challenge, it is likely that other chemokines or epithelial and plasma-derived molecules also participate. In conclusion, this study examining guinea pig eosinophil-rich tracheobronchial airways in vivo has demonstrated that the acute plasma exudation response to challenge with allergen or bradykinin is associated with an almost equally quick luminal entry of resident eosinophils. The speedy plasma exudation response by its content of pluripotent proteins appears instrumental to this cell traffic, and so may cell-derived chemokines that are transported by exuding plasma. For example, mucosal eotaxin appears to be moved promptly (within 120 s) to the mucosal surface along with extravasated bulk plasma that first has flooded the mucosal interstices. We propose that luminal entry of eosinophils is a significant component of the most acute phase of allergic reactions occurring in airways where these cells are already present in the mucosa. On a more general note, the present demonstration of acute luminal entry of potent leukocytes across the airway mucosa indicate a potential for prompt and efficient cellular host defense mechanisms getting into operation before infectious organisms or other topical insults have made their way into the tissue.
This study was funded by the Swedish Research Council, Medicine; the Vårdal Foundation; the Heart &Lung Foundation (Sweden); the National Asthma Campaign (UK); and the Wellcome Trust. The authors also thank Dr. Peter Jose for the antibody of guinea pig eotaxin. Received in original form January 15, 2003 Received in final form March 16, 2003
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||