Published ahead of print on March 23, 2004, doi:10.1165/rcmb.2004-0012OC
© 2004 American Thoracic Society DOI: 10.1165/rcmb.2004-0012OC Activation of Airway Cl Secretion in Human Subjects by AdenosineDepartments of Pediatrics and Medicine, the Gregory Fleming James Cystic Fibrosis Research Center, University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, Alabama; and Department of Human Genetics, Georgetown University, Washington, DC Address correspondence to: J. P. Clancy, M.D., Department of Pediatrics, 620 ACC, 1600 7th Avenue South, Birmingham, AL 35233. E-mail: jclancy{at}peds.uab.edu
We investigated cystic fibrosis (CF) transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) regulation by A2 adenosine (Ado) receptors and ß2 adrenergic receptors in CFTR-corrected CFBE41o- airway cells and human subjects. CFBE41o- cells stimulated with Ado (10 µM), isoproterenol (Iso, 10 µM), or Ado + Iso (10 µM each) elevated cyclic AMP (cAMP) above control conditions (P < 0.001), with the Iso conditions increasing cAMP 10-fold above that produced by Ado alone (P < 0.001). All agonist conditions had similar effects on short circuit current at 10 and 25 µM, with no further currents produced by subsequent stimulation with forskolin (20 µM). CFTR dependence was demonstrated by glybenclamide block of agonist-stimulated currents. Nasal potential difference studies in normal (n = 50) subjects demonstrated that Ado (10 µM) and Ado + Iso (10 µM each) produced more polarization compared with Iso (10 µM Ado increase = 44%, 10 µM Ado + Iso increase = 52%, P < 0.05 for each condition compared with Iso alone). Studies completed in patients with CF (n = 10, "severe" genotypes) confirmed that Ado-stimulated polarization was CFTR-dependent. Together, these results indicate that Ado is a potent Cl secretagogue in vivo, with relatively small effects on cAMP levels despite strong effects on CFTR-dependent short circuit current and nasal Cl transport. These findings support growing evidence indicating a role for Ado regulation of CFTR-dependent Cl secretion in vivo.
Abbreviations: ß2 adrenergic receptor, ß2 AR A2B adenosine receptor, A2B AR African American, AA adenosine, Ado A kinase anchoring proteins, AKAPs cyclic AMP, cAMP cystic fibrosis, CF CF transmembrane conductance regulator, CFTR G protein coupled receptor, GPCR short circuit current, Isc isoproterenol, Iso potential difference, P.D. protein kinase, PK
Cystic fibrosis (CF) is a common, lethal genetic disorder due to abnormal function of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator protein (CFTR). Defects in CFTR are manifest by abnormal ion transport in the epithelia where it is expressed, including absent cyclic AMP (cAMP)-stimulated anion secretion (1, 2). CFTR normally resides in the apical membrane of airway epithelia, and is found in both surface and glandular cells of the large and small airways (3). It is a member of the traffic ATPase family with inherent Cl channel activity (47). CFTR also positively regulates other Cl transport pathways (8) and downregulates Na+ transport (9). Activation of CFTR is complex, and is dependent upon ATP binding and hydrolysis at nucleotide binding domains 1 and 2, coupled with protein kinase (PK)A- and possibly PKC-dependent phosphorylation of its regulatory (R) domain (6, 1012). Regulation of CFTR in vivo is believed to be accomplished through activation of surface G proteincoupled receptors (GPCRs) that release Gs, stimulate adenyl cyclase, and raise cAMP, which in turns activates PKA. Two distinct GPCRs are expressed in airway epithelial cells and activate CFTR through this mechanism, including A2B adenosine receptors (A2B ARs), and ß2 adrenergic receptors (ß2 ARs). Both have been shown to couple to CFTR through spatial compartmentalization, but in different and incompletely understood ways. For example, recent studies by Huang and colleagues demonstrated that extracellular adenosine (Ado) could activate CFTR by stimulation of A2B ARs within a single, inside-out membrane patch (13). This activation was mediated through AKAP interactions, and indicated that all of the components necessary to activate CFTR through this receptor were found within the same patch of membrane. In addition to raising cAMP, Ado stimulates additional second messenger systems in Calu-3 and other CFTR-expressing epithelial cells that may also contribute to Cl transport (14, 15). ß2 ARs, on the other hand, contain a c-terminal PDZ-binding domain similar to that found in CFTR that provides a plausible mechanism for ß2 AR activation of CFTR through domain interactions mediated by ezrin-binding protein 50 (16, 17). Previously we found that Ado was a potent agonist of CFTR-dependent Cl transport in the nasal epithelium of mice, comparing favorably with ß receptor agonists (isoproterenol [Iso] and albuterol), in addition to stimulation with forskolin (15, 18). In the current study, we investigated the capacity of Ado to activate Cl transport in human surface airway cells expressing CFTR in vitro, and in the airway epithelium of human subjects. Ion transport was measured in vivo by the nasal potential difference assay in subjects with and without CF. We compared this with Cl secretion produced by Iso, a ß receptor agonist that is commonly used in human nasal potential difference (P.D.) assays to detect CFTR activity (19). Our studies provide evidence that Ado is a potent agonist of CFTR-dependent Cl secretion in vivo, and that addition of Ado to nasal P.D. protocols may improve our ability to detect CFTR activity in human subjects.
CFBE41o- Cell Culture, CFTR Expression, and Ussing Chamber Studies CFBE41o- cells ( F508/ F508) were the generous gift of Dr. D. Gruenert (University of San Francisco, San Francisco, CA) (20). Cells were grown in Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium/F12 media + 10% fetal bovine serum and 1% penicillin + streptomycin on fibronectin-coated tissue culture flasks until 90% confluent. The cells were then seeded onto 6.5-mm diameter fibronectin-coated Costar Transwell filters at a density of 5 x 105 cells/filter. Media was changed every other day on the basolateral surface until filters were confluent ( 5 d post seeding) with a resistance > 300 · cm, and then transfected with Ad5-CFTR (CFTR under regulatory control of the CMV promoter, contained in a replication deficient adenovirus vector with deletion of the E1A early genes; generous gift of Dr. J. Zabner, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA) at an MOI of 50 for 6 h. The transfecting media was then removed, and confluent cells were kept at an airliquid interface until 48 h after transfection (resistance of 300500 · cm). Inserts were mounted in an Ussing chamber, and short circuit current (Isc) was measured under voltage clamp conditions similar to previously described studies (15, 21). Briefly, cells grown at an airliquid interface were mounted in modified Ussing chambers (Jim's Instruments, Iowa City, IA), and initially bathed on both sides with identical Ringers solutions containing (mM) 115 NaCl, 25 NaHCO3, 2.4 KH2PO4, 1.24 K2HPO4, 1.2 CaCl2, 1.2 MgCl2, and 10 D-glucose (pH 7.4). Bath solutions were vigorously stirred and gassed with 5% CO2. Solutions and chambers were maintained at 37°C. Isc measurements were obtained by using an epithelial voltage clamp (University of Iowa Bioengineering, Iowa City, IA). A 3-mV pulse of 1 s duration was imposed every 100 s to monitor resistance, which was calculated using Ohm's law. To measure stimulated Isc, the mucosal bathing solution was changed to a low Cl solution containing (in mM) 1.2 NaCl, 115 Na gluconate, all other components as above, + 100 µM amiloride. Increasing concentrations of Ado or Iso were added to the mucosal bathing solutions as indicated (10 min of observation at each concentration), followed by 20 µM forskolin (mucosal and serosal). A quantity of 200 µM glybenclamide was added to the mucosal bathing solution, effectively blocking the stimulated Isc.
Detection of A2B ARs
Detection of cAMP
Human Nasal P.D. Studies
For each perfusion condition, a steady-state recording was obtained. The recording lasted at least 1 min (for Solutions A and B) before proceeding to the next solution within the sequence. Because the 3-min time point following the change to low [Cl]/Iso is taken as a highly sensitive and specific measure of wild-type CFTR activity, all patients and control subjects were monitored for at least 3 min during perfusion with Solutions C and D. To ensure standardization of the assay, measurements in this study were performed by the same three investigators using the same nasal PD apparatus. Several readings were obtained for data analysis, including: (i) "baseline P.D." as described above; (ii) "change due to amiloride" (the difference between the starting lactated Ringer's P.D. and the stable P.D. after perfusion with solution A); (iii) "change low [Cl]/10 µM agonist" (difference between the lowest stable P.D. following addition of amiloride before perfusion with solution C, and the P.D. after 3 min of perfusion with solution C); and (iv) "change low [Cl]/25 µM agonist" (difference between the completion of perfusion with solution C, and the P.D. after 3 min of perfusion with solution D). Tracings in patients and control subjects were not included in data analysis if catheter movement occurred. The final analysis included Each subject (50 normal control subjects, 10 patients with CF) was studied in all three conditions on separate occasions over a 2-wk period. The first and second P.D.s were performed with either Ado or Iso in an alternating fashion, and the third P.D. in the series was the combination of Ado and Iso. All nasal P.D. tracings were then coded by an investigator not involved in the study, such that all data were stripped of identifiers (including diagnosis or condition). Each nasal P.D was then scored independently by two investigators. The values for the above measurements were entered into a database, and mean values of both investigator scores for each nostril were tabulated and used for subsequent analysis.
Statistical Analysis
Stimulation of CFBE41o- Cells with Ado and Iso Raises cAMP and Activates Isc To compare the relationship between Ado and Iso stimulation of cAMP and Cl secretion in vitro, CFBE41o- cells were exposed to increasing concentrations of Ado, Iso, or the combination of Ado + Iso as described in MATERIALS AND METHODS. Figure 1A shows the effect of the agonists (10 µM) on cellular cAMP. Although all agonist conditions increased cAMP levels above control levels (compared with papaverine alone, P < 0.001) the Ado-stimulated cAMP was significantly less than the levels produced by Iso (P < 0.001). The combination of Ado and Iso failed to raise cAMP levels above that of Iso alone, indicating that maximal cAMP stimulation had been achieved. Complimentary studies performed in Calu-3 cells (airway serous cell phenotype) had similar results (Figure 1B). Figure 1C compares the effects of the agonist conditions on Isc in CFBE41o- cells expressing CFTR (48 h after transduction with Ad-CFTR as described in MATERIALS AND METHODS). In all three conditions, mucosal stimulation with 10 µM Ado, Iso, or Ado + Iso activated Isc. Higher concentrations of agonists (25 µM, mucosal) and subsequent stimulation with the potent cAMP-elevating agonist forskolin (20 µM, mucosal and serosal) failed to further increase Isc. Control conditions (no CFTR expression) failed to activate Isc by Ado, Iso, or forskolin. In previously reported studies performed in Calu-3 cell monolayers, we found similar CFTR activation by A2B AR and ß2 AR agonists (15, 17). Complimentary experiments evaluating the efficiency of Ad-GFP transduction indicated that 50% of CFBE41o- cells grown on permeable supports exhibited GFP expression under the same conditions as the Isc studies (Figure 1D). Figure 1E depicts a Western blot of CFBE41o- cell lysates, confirming A2B AR expression (right panel). Controls included identification of the receptor in a second airway epithelial cell line previously demonstrated to express this membrane protein (Calu-3 cells) (13, 15), and failure to detect A2B AR in HL60 cells (promyelocyte cell line; Figure 1E, left panel). Figure 1F shows an example of forskolin-activated Isc in CFBE41o- cells after Ad-CFTR transfection. Brisk activation is seen, and all of the stimulated current is sensitive to glybenclamide block. Together, these studies indicate that both Ado and Iso raise cAMP and activate CFTR-dependent Isc in CFTR-expressing human airway cells grown on permeable supports, and provide a dosing rationale for studies in human subjects. Similar patterns of activation of Isc were seen after stimulation with all three agonist conditions at 10 µM, despite large differences in cAMP production by Ado compared with Iso (Figures 1A and 1B).
Ado Activates CFTR-Dependent Cl Transport in Human Subjects Based on the results of our in vitro studies and our previous experience in murine nasal P.D. measurements, we investigated the effects of Ado on ion transport in human subjects using the nasal P.D. assay. This bioelectric measurement of airway ion transport is frequently used to detect CFTR function, and to discriminate between a normal and a CF phenotype. For these studies, we used a protocol similar to that shown in our in vitro experiments, comparing Ado, Iso, and the combination of Ado and Iso at two concentrations (10 and 25 µM). We chose to investigate relatively low doses of Ado based on our findings in CFTR-corrected CFBE41o- cells, and because high concentrations of Ado have previously been suggested to elicit mast cell degranulation in human nasal studies (23).
Table 1 summarizes demographic information in the control subjects and in subjects with CF. For the group without CF, there was a slightly higher incidence of female participants (70% in control subjects versus 60% in subjects with CF) and higher mean age than the CF group. The subjects with CF all carried the diagnosis of CF based on positive sweat Cl values, disease involving at last two organ systems, and the identification of two class I, II, or III CF-causing mutations. Nine out of ten subjects with CF were homozygous for the
Table 2 summarizes nasal P.D. results in our normal subjects for the three agonist conditions. Data shown are the mean (± SD) from individual nostrils (two measurements/subject). Similar results were obtained when data were analyzed as mean P.D. change for both nostrils per subject and "best response" per subject (data not shown). As expected, the baseline, amiloride-sensitive, and low [Cl] + amiloride components of the nasal P.D. were similar across the 3 d of study for each condition. No statistically significant differences were found for any of these parameters for the different days of study. A quantity of 10 µM Ado and Ado + Iso produced greater polarization than 10 µM Iso alone, with a 44% (Ado) and a 52% (Ado + Iso) increase in stimulated P.D. (P < 0.05, also see Figure 2 for comparisons of stimulated Cl secretion within the normal group). Further stimulation with 25 µM agonist (3-min perfusion) produced minimal further polarization in any of the three conditions (NS). When comparing the change in P.D. after perfusion with amiloride + low [Cl-] + 10 µM agonist, the mean stimulated P.D. for both the Ado and the Ado + Iso conditions were mildly increased over the Iso condition alone (P > 0.05). The additional 3-min perfusion with 25 µM agonist increased the total measured Cl secretion slightly in all three conditions.
Table 3 summarizes nasal P.D. results for our subjects with CF. Data shown are the mean (± SD) from individual nostrils (two measurements/subject). Similar results were obtained when data were analyzed as mean P.D. change for both nostrils per subject and "best response" per subject (data not shown). As expected, differences between the group with CF and the control group were seen for all measured parameters for each agonist condition (P < 0.001). For comparisons of conditions within the group with CF, no differences were seen in terms of baseline, amiloride-sensitive P.D., and the change in P.D. after perfusion with amiloride + low [Cl] for the different days of study. For comparisons of the change in P.D. after agonist perfusion, the Ado and Ado + Iso conditions displayed less depolarization than the Iso condition alone. There was a trend toward significance for the change in P.D. after perfusion with low [Cl] solution + amiloride + Ado (10 µM), and the change in P.D. after perfusion with low [Cl] + amiloride + [Ado + Iso (10 µM)] compared with low [Cl] + amiloride + Iso alone (10 µM, 0.05 < P < 0.10, see Table 3). Figure 3 shows mean and individual responses (scatter points) for the group with CF after perfusion with solutions B and C (Low [Cl]/amiloride/10 µM agonist, right panel).
Figure 4 shows the sequential nasal P.D. measures of Cl secretion (Solutions B and C, change in P.D. after perfusion with low [Cl] + amiloride + 10 µM agonist) in our control subjects (150), whereas Figure 5 shows similar data for our subjects with CF (110). Each value is the mean (± SD) of the six separate nasal P.D. readings (two nostrils, three agonist conditions) obtained for each subject. There was no consistent trend seen in the magnitude of Cl secretory responses in the normal group obtained over the course of the study ( 24 mo) except for poor detection of Cl secretion during an isolated period in the normal group (subjects 1421), suggesting that time or accumulated experience was not a contributing factor to the results. On review of our records, the failure to detect Cl secretion in normal subjects 1421 was believed to be due to erroneous storage of agar bridges for this period in a low electrolyte solution. Because we could not definitely exclude other etiologies for the reduced responses, data from these subjects was included in the final analysis. Similar Cl secretory results were obtained in the normal group when the data from these individuals were excluded (change P.D. [mV ± S.D.] 10 µM drug [*Ado = 8.09 {7.92}, Ado + Iso = 7.48 {7.97}, Iso = 5.17 {6.46}] *P = 0.001 compared with Iso, P = 0.077; change low [Cl] + 10 µM drug [Ado = 19.82 {15.01}, Ado + Iso = 19.17 {14.21}, Iso = 19.17 {14.21}]). Data variability also remained relatively stable throughout the course of the study. Similar measurements for the group with CF (Figure 5) showed no consistent trend in this value over the course of the study.
The results of our study establish that Ado is a potent Cl secretagogue in vivo, activating CFTR-dependent Cl transport across the nasal epithelium of normal subjects. The change in potential difference produced by 10 µM Ado was greater than that seen with Iso alone, and similar to that seen with Ado + Iso (10 µM, P < 0.05 for Ado and Ado+ Iso compared with Iso alone). This difference was lost with 25 µM agonists, suggesting that all conditions achieved maximal activation of CFTR at the higher concentration studied. When combined with the change in P.D. after perfusion with amiloride + low [Cl] solution, similar trends were seen for all three experimental conditions after 3 min of perfusion with 10 µM agonists, and after subsequent perfusion for 3 min with 25 µM agonists.
Using an in vitro human airway cell model of Cl- transport, both Ado and Iso potently stimulated CFTR-dependent Cl secretion. Interestingly, similar patterns of Cl transport were seen in all three agonist conditions, despite large ( Recent studies by Donaldson and colleagues highlight purinergic levels and regulation of Cl secretion and CFTR in airway cells (13, 26, 27). Some of these data suggest that Ado, A2B Ado receptors, and CFTR may play a pivotal role in setting the airway surface liquid depth in primary human airway cell monolayer cultures, and in this way serve as a natural regulator of CFTR activity in vivo. A2B AR regulation of CFTR has also been described in Calu-3 cells, a serous glandular cell line that expresses high levels of CFTR (13, 15, 21). Glandular function has been a topic of considerable interest in CF, and work by Joo and colleagues (28) and Ballard and coworkers (29) have recently addressed the importance of airway gland function in CF pathogenesis. Phosphorylated nucleosides such as ATP and UTP have been shown to activate CFTR-independent Cl secretion in normal and CF airway epithelial cell cultures and in human subjects through stimulation of P2Y2 purinergic receptors (30, 31). We recently reported that phosphorylated Ado nucleosides, including ATP, ADP, and AMP, all contribute to the regulation of anion secretion in Calu-3 cells through A2 receptors, presumably through dephosphorylation by surface ectonucleotidases (21). P2 purinergic receptors, in contrast, appear to play a relatively limited role in anion secretion in these cells. Together, these studies highlight the significance of Ado as a signaling molecule to regulate CFTR activity, and the importance of understanding the role of this regulatory pathway in both glandular secretion and CF pathogenesis.
The nasal P.D. results observed in subjects with CF (Table 3 and Figure 3) suggest that Ado may have very small Cl stimulatory effects in some subjects beyond that seen with Iso. The nature of this effect is unknown, but previous studies from our laboratory have shown that Ado stimulation of A2B ARs can activate surface localized mutant CFTR molecules, including Ado is a ubiquitous signaling molecule, contributing to regulation of a variety of organ processes, ranging from ion transport and inflammation to neural function, vascular tone, and cardiac activity (36). Ado has been shown to signal mast cell degranulation, and after metabolism from AMP may serve as a bronchoprovocative agent to detect allergic-based asthma in human subjects (37). AMP has been found to be quite specific in this regard, as studies in normal subjects and a limited number of control patients with airway disease did not induce bronchoconstriction. Based on Ado's extremely short half life (seconds) and its possible role in provoking bronchoconstriction, it appears unlikely that the parent molecule (adenosine) would serve a therapeutic, lower airway role in the treatment of CF. A better understanding of Ado signaling in airway cells, however, may identify additional physiologic regulators of Cl secretion and CFTR. Finally, performance of the nasal potential difference in human subjects has the potential for multiple technique-related inaccuracies, which may have been responsible for the unusually low Cl secretory responses seen with all agonists for normal subjects 1421 (Figure 4). Subsequent to this study, Standard Operating Procedures for performance of the nasal P.D. have been developed by the Cystic Fibrosis Therapeutic Development Network. As researchers continue to refine this endpoint for studies of airway ion transport in vivo, standardized procedures coupled with meticulous execution and data review need to be employed in an ongoing fashion to ensure that results from protocols (particularly multi-center studies) continue to provide useful, reproducible, and meaningful data. In summary, our results indicate that Ado is a potent activator of CFTR-dependent Cl transport in human subjects. It compares favorably with the current gold standard ß2 AR agonist (Iso), increasing mean stimulated Cl secretion at lower concentrations. Future nasal P.D. studies of Ado compared with Iso in patients with CF carrying partial function CFTR mutations, or with retained pulmonary function, may provide useful information regarding the relative contribution of these two pathways to airway ion transport in subjects with various disease manifestations.
Research was supported by the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute (HL67088) the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation (CFF R464), the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (P30 DK54781, P50 DK53090), and the National Center for Research Resources (M01 RR00032). The authors thank Cassie Woodley for her expert help in preparing this manuscript.
Conflict of Interest Statement: K.H.-F. has no declared conflict of interest; D.L. has no declared conflict of interest; V.E.-T has no declared conflict of interest; B.C. has no declared conflict of interest; L.F. has no declared conflict of interest; R.O. has no declared conflict of interest; E.S. has no declared conflict of interest; and J.P.C. has no declared conflict of interest.
* Both authors contributed equally to the work included in this manuscript. Received in original form January 12, 2004 Received in final form March 8, 2004
This article has been cited by other articles:
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||